Matthew Schaefer scored his first NHL hat trick in the New York Islanders' 5-1 win over Columbus, becoming the first Islanders defenseman to achieve the feat since Denis Potvin in 1982. Matthew Schaefer scored a hat trick in the Islanders’ 5-1 win over the Blue Jackets on Nov. 17, giving New York its first three-game winning streak in over eight months and joining rare teenage.